1. Home
  2. US
  3. New York
  4. Suffolk County
  5. Plum Island

Hotels Near Plum Island

Best deals on the hotels closest to this island in Suffolk County, New York

Current filter: 2-star hotels

Days Inn by Wyndham Niantic Near Casinos
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

239 Flanders Road - Niantic - 12.1 miles from Plum Island

Near Cedar Ridge Golf Course
Starlight Inn
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

256 Flanders Road - East Lyme - 12.3 miles from Plum Island

Near Cedar Ridge Golf Course
Motel 6 New London - Niantic
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

269 Flanders Rd - Niantic - 12.4 miles from Plum Island

Near Cedar Ridge Golf Course
Sleep Inn & Suites
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

5 King Arthur Dr - Niantic - 12.4 miles from Plum Island

Near Cedar Ridge Golf Course
Liberty Inn
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

55 Springbrook Road - Old Saybrook - 12.7 miles from Plum Island

Near Katharine Hepburn Cultural Arts Center
Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

100 Essex Rd - Old Saybrook - 12.8 miles from Plum Island

Near Florence Griswold Museum
Rodeway Inn Waterford - New London
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

211 Parkway North - Waterford - 13.1 miles from Plum Island

Near Crystal Mall
Pier Blue Guesthouse
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

1430 Boston Post Rd - Old Saybrook - 13.3 miles from Plum Island

In Old Saybrook (Saybrook Manor)
Red Roof Inn Mystic - New London
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

707 Colman Street - New London - 13.7 miles from Plum Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Clarion Inn New London - Mystic
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

269 North Frontage Road - New London - 13.8 miles from Plum Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Americas Best Value Inn New London Mystic
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

380 Bayonet Street - New London - 13.8 miles from Plum Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook Westbrook
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

1750 Boston Post Rd - Old Saybrook - 13.8 miles from Plum Island

In Old Saybrook (Westbrook Center)
Super 8 by Wyndham Old Saybrook
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

37 Spencer Plain Rd - Old Saybrook - 13.9 miles from Plum Island

In Old Saybrook (Westbrook Center)
Motel 6 Groton CT
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

404 Bridge St - Groton - 14.0 miles from Plum Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Hampton Inn Groton/Mystic/New London
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

300 Long Hill Rd - Groton - 14.0 miles from Plum Island

Near Fort Griswold Battlefield State Park
Rodeway Inn
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

425 Bridge St - Groton - 14.0 miles from Plum Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Super 8 by Wyndham Groton
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

173, Route 12 - Groton - 14.4 miles from Plum Island

Near United States Coast Guard Academy
Ramada by Wyndham Groton
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

156 Kings Hwy - Groton - 14.6 miles from Plum Island

Near Fort Griswold Battlefield State Park
Sunset Beach Motel
Click for the best price at TheHotelNexus.com

540 West Lake Drive - Montauk - 15.0 miles from Plum Island

In Montauk (Culloden Shores)
Flagship Inn And Suites
Book it now at a great price at TheRealPlaces!

Route 184 - 470 Gold Star Hwy - Groton - 15.1 miles from Plum Island

Near Naval Submarine Base New London